Raising Her Head: Goddess Resurgence and Pagan Responsibility

Me in 1966: raised on barbecue
Me in 1966: raised on barbecue

“For you men who still do not know I will give one further clue. Look into yourself – look into your heart. Do you see who it is who lies there, in a sleep near to death, a sleep that has lasted for centuries, a sleep from which you can awaken Her?”

Daniel Cohen, Iphegenia: A Retelling

“This Revolution is genuine because it was born from the same womb that always gives birth to massive social upheavals – the womb of intolerable conditions and unendurable situations.”
―Martin Luther King, Jr.  Why We Can’t Wait

I preempt this entire post with a disclaimer:  Not all Christians are mindless, hate-mongering, uneducated bigots.  In fact, in my personal experience (not the media), I have found them to be kind, giving, open-minded (occasionally misguided) folks.  Many are my friends, and many are aware that I am a pagan witch; some even support my faith as “my way up the mountain.”  The trouble is, and will always be, that these kind souls are usually not the ones quoted in the media, or holding a sign on campus, or verbally forthright in our communities.  Their presence, holy in its own way, is thereby unrecorded or (worse) unnoticed in the outright religious brawl that is bubbling on the horizon.

We have seen it coming, haven’t we?  Oh, we might not post about it on Faceplant or talk about it in public forums, but we smell it just around yonder tree and have struggled to be encouraged by the increasingly prevalent Pagan resurgence on our planet.  On the one hand, I am grateful that I will witness at least a moment of where we are going; on the other, I am terrified for my son.

Jeanne Tao writes in “Pagan Presence May Not Be Loud, But Earth-Worship Experiences a Revival,” of the misconceptions of modern-day pagans:

Although most pagan traditions insist on respect for all living things and especially for the environment, many are still negatively stereotyped and wrongly imagined by some to be Satanists. Because of this stigma, they tend to keep a low profile, often practicing privately and preferring anonymity.

And y’all, this is some serious stigma.  Heather Greene sums up the very real threat to witches and pagans everywhere when responding to the now infamous “Witches Must Die By Fire” Facebook page:

Now that the pages are down, we can move beyond that surreal point back into the security of our own world. Unfortunately, the removal of these two Facebook pages created no comfort for those living in the affected regions of Africa or elsewhere. Should this week’s events be a wake-up call for Pagans and Witches worldwide to reconsider our relationship with the accused? Now that the “fire” is put out, should we re-evaluate our responsibility, as a People who claim the word Witch, to those people who are dying because of the word witch? 

This very real threat, however, did not disappear upon the removal of a Faceplant page.  On the heels of movies like Hansel and Gretel: Witch Hunters (2013), as well as episodes on shows such as Bones, “The Witch in the Wardrobe” (2010) that either situate witches as evil and demonic (as in the former) or silly, murderous Wiccans who cannot control themselves and are subject to hallucinogens (as in the latter), we can no longer *assume* that we are safe.  Nor should we.  And this, Batchildren, is not all:  the resurgence of Pagan religions across the globe has caught the attention of Christian church leaders.

I know, I know.  How dangerous can they be?

Um . . .

Last night, I caught a headline in my newsfeed.  The article was entitled: “Epidemic of babies thrown into trash cans a revival of pagan custom of ‘exposure’: Catholic deacon,” written by Ben Johnson for LifeSiteNews.com.

At first, I thought: well, boy howdy.  Y’all are just slinging crosses at shadows again!  I found it . . . almost quaint.  And then, I read more:

The ongoing rash of babies being flushed down toilets, abandoned in dumpsters, or thrown into trash cans signals the return of an ancient pagan practice completely compatible with our abortion culture, according to a prominent Catholic deacon.

“This situation amounts to a modern resurgence of the ancient pagan practice once called exposure,” wrote Deacon Keith Fournier in a recent article. “Unwanted babies were left out on rocks to be eaten by birds of prey or taken by slave traders.”

Deacon Keith Fournier says the Culture of Death is alive and

Deacon Keith Fournier says the Culture of Death is alive and well [1]

That brutal cultural indifference came to an end with the rise of a new faith. “It was the Christians who saved [these babies] and transformed those cultures from cultures of death into cultures of life,” wrote Fournier.

Now, paganism is resurgent, and its anti-life ethic with it.

After taking a deep breath, I entered a comment (it was in moderation, it has apparently now been removed completely):

How dare you? I am a Pagan minister and “life,” including utero, is critical to our tenets and our sacred responsibility. Hate mongering like this, with inaccurate facts and leading assumptions, are born of fear at best and political manipulation at worst. Obviously, your desire to find an evil faction who are responsible overwhelms your desire to end the evil. Be careful, “Father.” It may be Pagans, whose primary concern is always that of life and its beauty and sacredness, that will save those children. Your time is waning. As are your lies. Perhaps you should examine your faction’s own abuse to children (are they allowed a safe place without bad touch?) before you heap unwarranted blame upon our heads? [2]

Of course, it may be the “bad touch” comment that got me ousted–ironic, if you consider the “Father’s” public and allowable accusation that we encourage a culture of death and murder–and I recognize that very few followers of this extremely right-wing, Catholic propaganda would hear me out, anyway.  So.  I turn to you, my Pagan kin as well as my Christian loved ones to say:

Of course, “they” will never change their minds.  Why should they?  Within their grasp, for several thousand years, there were golden and powerful political gains to be had, empires to be funded and the masses to be controlled.  Why, even their own people have been silenced and policed and disarmed–well past their own sacred belief systems of universal love, justice and charity.  If we wait for acceptance, we will suffer the same fate of our ancestors: ostracization, demonization and even physical threat.  While the Christian Right enjoys public celebration of their faith, we cower . . . hoping that if we are discovered, there will be mercy and tolerance.  Tolerance.  Towards a people and a faith who have worshipped for (at the very least) 30,000 years on the Earth.  Tolerance.  Towards a faith that reveres life in all of its stages, people in all of their colors and sexualities and religions, the planet in all of her natural manifestations.  Tolerance.  We wait for tolerance?

I want more for my child than tolerance.  And I live in the Bible Belt.

Show me?  I don't see the evil.
Show me? I don’t see the evil.

We know that we are not a “death culture,” nor are we evil.  And an outright revolt?  Why, that would produce the same negative fervor of those who would stake us.

“The conservatives who say, ‘Let us not move so fast,’ and the extremists who say, ‘Let us go out and whip the world ,’ would tell you that they are as far apart as the poles. But there is a striking parallel: They accomplish nothing; for they do not reach the people who have a crying need to be free.”   Martin Luther King, Jr.  Why We Can’t Wait

And, goddess knows, I’m not sure of the right thing–but here’s what I reckon:  If we keep talking to our Christian friends, let them know us and our sacred ways, resist the temptation to hate monger, push against ignorance and fight for clarity and do so with our heads held high and our foundation firm . . . maybe there’s hope.  But, as I stated in my last blog: we cannot idly stand by and be complicit about those who would echo (by their actions or their stance) the Christian Right’s condemnation of us as “bad” or “evil.”  We do not have that luxury.  There is too much at stake.  What we do and who we are is now part and parcel of a public conversation–and the world will take us at our word and our wyrd.  If I perpetuate the stigma and history of “bad” witchcraft, even if only for irony or publicity, I am responsible for the furthering of Deacon Fournier’s supposed evidence that we are a “culture of death,” a culture of evil curses and dark dogma.  Would I be within my rights?  Is this a free country?  Doesn’t anyone have a sense of humor?

Good grief.  Do we have time for that kind of self-serving propaganda in this day and age?  At what cost?

Yes, yes.  We are magic.  We know what we are capable of . . . and many of us cave to ego and desire from time to time.  I contend that this is a human trait, not a witch one.  However, as (appropriately, I suppose) unorganized as we may be:  there must be something we are all proud to bring to the table.  That dish, my friends, should be at every event:

Children are sacred.  Hands off.
Life is sacred.  Protect it.
Energy runs through us.  Be responsible.
Lying, manipulation, maliciousness are not tenets of Paganism.
Respect for all, regardless of (fill in the blank) IS a tenet of Paganism.
There is an “afterlife.”  Work towards it.
Stand up for that which is noble, decent and/or innocent.
Educate, educate, educate.  And not just your own kin.  Knowledge isn’t just power: it’s freedom.


We have a revolution on our hands, Batchildren.  What they record about us today will be the tapestry our children’s lives are woven into, thread by thread.  Are we “bad?”  No?

Then let’s not weave it into the quilt of memory, shall we?

My existence is sacred upon this Earth.  I am the echo of my Big Momma, a flawed, magical example of humanity at its worst, at its best, twisting and turning toward forever in an eternal dance.  I have never been, nor will I ever be, a bad witch: for the two are incompatible, incomprehensible within such an ethereal state.  Rather, I am wind and fire, earth and water, natural and holy, fleshly and otherworldly.  I am witch.  Period.  The  physical manifestation of my ancestors who fought for freedom, who stood by muggles even in their darkest hour, who held the hand of “sinners” so that they might redeem themselves.  I am a child of the dark and the light, a daughter of the Great Mother, and I will never, ever be forgotten nor remembered as bad. [3]

Our history is rising from the ashes, too, twisting, turning towards the moon, the sun.  In what light will it find us?

May we all see the end of Pagan persecution in our lifetimes, and if not, may we all have a hand in its demise.

Blessed Be,


1.  Seriously.  Does anyone else get the shivers looking at this photo?

2.  Upon publication of this blog, my comment is still MIA.

3.  Not all Pagans worship a goddess.  As my own religion finds Her primary, I have taken the liberty of addressing my deity here.  (We are very, very diverse!)

20 Comments on “Raising Her Head: Goddess Resurgence and Pagan Responsibility

  1. Seba, you are a wonderful, feisty, spicy woman, and I am blessed and happy that I’ve found your blog and friendship on Faceplant! 🙂 You are indeed a blessing to all who know you! ~Kelly

  2. seba, thank you so much for the renewal you give me every time I read your blog.

  3. Rebecca Hamilton, whose blog “Public Catholic” is on Patheos.com, loves to declare any action she doesn’t like “pagan”. There’s a current of this in modern Catholicism, it seems. Whenever I get homesick for my religion of origin, something like this pops up to validate my decision to leave.

    • I’ve never looked back after I left the religion I was raised in. In fact I found the craft of the wise when I was just 10 yrs old already fed up with the Catholic values. I was verbally bullied & often wanted someone to give the boy who started it all an expulsion from the school. But instead of punishing him – I was told to be more like Christ & ‘turn the other cheek’. I was outgoing & talkative before the fourth grade, during the fourth grade I became shy & quiet. I could find no peace within, no matter how hard I prayed.

      Then at the library I found one book. I was super drawn to it. I read the forward & new instantly that ‘witch’ is what I am. I had 8 more years to survive as a witch in Catholic schools, the pagan books I read built me up on the inside & made me not cower, made me strong – though I was quite shy till my senior year. But once I was out of the parochial school system, I did tell the pastor of the church I was raised & had to attend, in an open confession (face-to-face). He smiled at me & stood up & patted my shoulder & the squatted so he was eye to eye and told me, “there are many paths to the spirituality that every human seeks. We all cannot be Catholic, or even Christian. Many of us need to explore & find the path that feels best to our hearts.”

  4. thank you for posting this. I have forwarded it to my brother who is a Catholic priest. In the 28 years that I have been a Pagan I have never come out to him. He knows I don’t attend church and haven’t for years. I just want him to see that Pagans are good people, we have our beliefs and tenets also. We can be your neighbor and we can even be a sibling who just want equal respect in our beliefs. Thank you for putting in writing what I have been feeling but couldn’t find the right words to express myself correctly.

  5. Blessed Be, Seba. Thank you for sharing your talent at communicating. I outed myself publicly as Pagan a few years back and now it’s just casual that people know. Most of the response has been at least polite, and most of them genuinely.

    Last summer this was published: http://www.whole-dog-journal.com/blog/Dog-Funeral-Planning-20637-1.html . I wrote it, put it on my own blog and was contacted by Whole Dog Journal wanting to use it. It has nothing to do with funeral planning, it’s called The Pagan Dog Funeral and it’s about what happened here in my neighborhood last summer. I was so proud of it, even though they did a bit of a hack job editing it, most of it survived. (original can be found here http://dogsbeerandchocolate.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-pagan-dog-funeral.html) What was most interesting was the comments, which I tend not to read when I publish in a magazine I generally don’t like. Overwhelming support, with a few bible verse weapons tossed in by a couple people. The neighbor, bless her heart, still asks for help when she needs it and I keep giving it.

  6. I am a labor and delivery nurse, and I work in an institution that does the much maligmen ‘late term abortion’. It is not a convenient form of birth control. 95%of these mamas have a baby with enough anomalies that it might die in utero, or shortly after birth. Most of these mamas decide to induce labor, so they can deliver a live baby they can love on, for all the time they are given with their baby.

    I would love to have a very righteous person who is lucky enough to see life in only black and white walk my walk at work with me.

    To hold the hand of a woman losing a much wanted baby. To help her find her strength, teach her to grieve. (Oh, and do the nursing care to keep her physically safe) and if her baby has delivered and passed over, make photos and a memory box.

    Would that the judgmental could walk the high risk antepartum unit, where it is 1/4 nursing care and 9/4 emotional support and hope. I know that the algebra of giving 10 4 or 5 patients is a mathematic problem. And let them see the transition when a high risk mom needs to prepare for delivery. While I do the nuse stuff. And support her. As best I can.

    But I got 2 hugs this wwek from mamas who told me I made a differece in their journry. That means more to me than the paycheck. (Tho the paychech supports my family)

    I do love my job. I. Wish the small minded. Could open their heats.

  7. u no i se alot of this and it upsets me to think this preist can say such things when after al the things they have ben caught at 2 this day.im am aproud pagan a dad of 5 my wife is christain and new that i was pagan before we got together.however i am oposed to such things cause it keps getin worse 4 us i think thier tryin to hide there own crimes against kids with trash like this

  8. Sing it loud, sing it proud, sistah! Yes! I also want more than tolerance for our future.

  9. Seba, my Darlin Gal!!

    I WILL be sharing this blog with everyone I can find to help spread the message contained inside. You are a blessing to us all and I am honored to call you friend.

  10. People who know me are used to me saying that “I’ll pray in anybody’s church.” Truly…I can find the divine in the frozen food aisle of Shop-N-Save. They all think it’s because I’m an anthropologist and a writer–open minded. But I know that it is because of my inherently pagan nature. Even though I was born a Catholic, I recognize that great faith as only one dialect of a universal language–that of the creator in all his-her-its glorious forms. At the same time, I’m shy. I tend to keep myself to myself. But it may be time for a change. I’ve noticed hints. For the first time in twenty years of writing, Wiccans are appearing as main characters in my fiction. Also, I’ve been dreaming about witches nearly every night for the past few weeks. Groups of witches. I’m a solitary, so this is strange for me. And, when I think about my autumn decorating scheme, why do I keep seeing a grapevine pentagram decorated with cranberries hanging from my front door? I live in the middle of Las Vegas within walking distance of TWO Mormon churches. Neighbors WILL SEE it. But I can’t get it out of my head.

    Maybe it’s time for a change.

    Has anyone ever started a revolution with a glue gun and some 1″-wide grosgrain ribbon?

  11. Well said Seba!!!!!!! I applaud you!
    On a different topic, everybody check out the Cucuteni-Trypillian culture (start with Wiki). As far back as 4800 BC these people celebrated and worshiped the Goddess, of course Goddess worship is even older than 4800 BC! They even had a written script which has not been deciphered as of yet, but have found the symbols of it far and wide within other cultures. I just thought this was cool and turn everybody on to it!!!! The pottery is amazing!
    Blessed be!!!!!!

  12. Well said. I’ve just joined this blog and find your writing powerful and honest.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: